Even after finishing a project you’re confident about, a tiny inner voice nags: “Sure, but is it perfect?”. It lingers until you reopen the work, and before hitting send, you end up spending another three hours on meticulous checks and needless tweaks.
If that sounds familiar, ask yourself: did those extra three hours of stress and anxiety over “perfection” actually make your project any better than it was originally? Some people might send an email with a minor typo and feel a twinge of embarrassment. Others, however, turn a single slip into total humiliation, punishing themselves all day long - these are the perfectionists.
First, it’s important to note that perfectionism isn’t all bad (Stoeber and Otto, 2006). People with this trait are often highly motivated, bring unique value to their teams, take pride in their work, and spot errors that others might miss, thanks to their keen attention to detail. They strive to improve in every aspect of life and can juggle multiple tasks and responsibilities simultaneously.
These are positive traits, but to truly benefit from them, we need to keep the drive for impossible perfection in check. Left unchecked, even though perfectionism is common among successful people, at its extreme it breeds anxiety, panic, procrastination, and even paralysis.
I am worthy because of what I have done, not because of who I am
Perfectionists often tie their identity and self-worth to external validation. They feel good about themselves only when they succeed at work, when friends and family approve of their relationships, when they’re popular, or financially secure.
The problem is that when our self-worth depends on external factors, we may feel secure, thinking our achievements and possessions are stable, but this is an illusion. What exists today might be gone tomorrow, and when it is, perfectionism can make us leap to the conclusion that we’ve failed. As a result, we experience anxiety, anguish, panic, or even giving up.
The only truly stable thing we can rely on is what we carry within us, our sense of self. When we acknowledge who we are, external changes affect us less, helping us avoid negative emotions and temper our perfectionist tendencies.
Perfectionism as a harsh critic of everything
We cannot want to be "perfect" and not expect the same from the people around us, especially at work, and also in our personal life. So what problems can arise?
A perfectionist employer struggles with employee mistakes or oversights. They may come across as harsh, anxious, or rigid, making them hard to work with. Their relentless pursuit of perfection and low tolerance for errors often results in lower productivity, poor communication, a tense work environment, and high staff turnover. In the long run, this can impact the business overall.
A perfectionist employee, whether in a senior position or lower in the hierarchy, may face anything from burnout symptoms to resignation. Their need to deliver the "perfect result" can make them unfairly competitive, and also inconsistent with deadlines. They may seem unsuitable to take on demanding projects because anxiety overwhelms them, and they may also significantly underperform in teamwork. A perfectionist tends not to trust others easily, judging them as less capable or less effective than themselves, which makes it difficult to ask for help, delegate tasks, or work as part of a team. Finally, the tendency to constantly judge mistakes as failures, rather than as learning about areas for improvement, can lead a perfectionist employee in a senior role to manage their team ineffectively. They may take on tasks and projects that their team should handle, resulting in exhaustion or poor performance, and for that, they often do not take responsibility but instead place the blame on their subordinates.
A perfectionist partner can inadvertently sabotage a relationship. Their intense criticism can spark conflict, insecurity, and disappointment, sometimes leading to separation. Anything short of their high, often unspoken, standards feels like failure, including conflicts, which only heighten stress even after attempts to mend things.The worst part is that even conflicts are seen as failure, so each conflict adds more discomfort, disappointment, and anxiety, even when it is followed by attempts to repair things.
Perfectionism as armor
Perfectionism always revolves around "How do others see me?". We wear it like armor, carrying it from our parents’ home into our own family, relationships, work, and social life, all in pursuit of acceptance and approval.
As long as we appear strong, smart, fast, always well-groomed, flawless, and unaffected by any "weakness" (a word we do not want associated with us), we feel safe that others see us that way too, whether they matter to us or not. The trouble with this “armor of perfectionism” is that, while we think it shields us, it actually hides us. The more we conceal our true selves, the less we understand who we are. And the less we reveal to others, the more we remain strangers to those who “accept” us for something that isn’t truly us.
Until the armor rusts and falls away, we’re forced to face ourselves bare. And then what? Will life accept us? Don’t wait for the armor to break on its own-take it off yourself, in your own time, in your own way, whether on your own or with professional guidance.
Because it’s both challenging and wonderful to let go of perfection and simply be yourself…
By Mary Spathari, psychologist | 06/11/2020
